American Idol 'American Idol' eliminee Tristan McIntosh: Jennifer Lopez's criticism surprised me a bit 03/20/2016 American Idol determined its farewell season's Top 5 finalists and eliminated Tristan McIntosh in the process during Thursday night's broadcast on Fox. Read More RELATED NEWS 'American Idol,' 'The Bachelor,' 'The Bachelorette' and 'Shark Tank' all renewed by ABCKeith Urban, Carrie Underwood, Lauren Alaina and Jason Derulo win big at 2017 CMT Music AwardsKaty Perry reveals details of Taylor Swift feud -- "She started it" TAGS: American Idol Harry Connick Jr. Jennifer Lopez Keith Urban Martina McBride Tristan McIntosh
