American Idol Fox: 'American Idol' Top 12 finals to feature controversial "big surprise" 01/19/2009 A big surprise is apparently awaiting American Idol's Top 12 eighth-season finalists. Read More RELATED NEWS Adam Lambert releasing new EP in SeptemberAdam Lambert "still friends" with Sam Smith after accidental postAdam Lambert and boyfriend Javi Costa Polo go Instagram official TAGS: American Idol Kelly Clarkson Mike Darnell