American Idol Pia Toscano never was a frontrunner, 'American Idol' producer says 04/11/2011 Pia Toscano's American Idol elimination was a huge shock to viewers, however the tenth-season finalist's ouster apparently wasn't a surprise to Nigel Lythgoe. Read More RELATED NEWS 'American Idol' runner-up Lauren Alaina calls off engagement to high school sweetheart Alex Hopkins'American Idol' winner Scotty McCreery marries Gabi DugalScotty McCreery: I forgot there was a gun in the backpack I took to airport TAGS: American Idol So You Think You Can Dance Casey Abrams Lauren Alaina Fantasia Barrino Crystal Bowersox Kelly Clarkson Randy Jackson Jennifer Lopez Paul McDonald Haley Reinhart Pia Toscano Steven Tyler Carrie Underwood
